Those
Girls: Single Women in Sixties and Seventies Popular Culture.
Katherine
J. Lehman. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas,
2011.
280 pp. $29.95 cloth.
The lives and agencies
of single women have been the subject of
numerous popular
culture offerings for decades. The critical attention
given to the Sex
and the City television series and subsequent films
and debates surrounding
the new HBO series Girls speak to the continued
efficacy (and
controversial nature) of “single girl” narratives.
The single girl,
however, arguably had her heyday during the 1960s
and 1970s. This period
is the subject of Katherine J. Lehman’s Those
Girls: Single
Women in Sixties and Seventies Popular Culture.
Those Girls focuses
on television shows and films featuring young,
never-married women.
Lehman describes the single woman as “a pivotal
figure in postwar
popular culture who helped viewers negotiate
sweeping changes in
gender roles and sexual mores” (1). She argues
that the liberated
woman onscreen, “opened up new avenues for
female representation
in the media,” however, “producers and censors
often tamed the single
woman’s sexuality and strength” (2). It is this
focus on the
behind-the-scenes negotiations regarding the single
girl’s representation
that make Lehman’s work unique. Examining
who has the power to
change characters and plots before an audience
has a chance to see a
film or television show (as well as what types
of changes are made
and why) can oftentimes be incredibly instructive.
Indeed, it is in the
process of adaptation and revision that the
possibilities and
limitations inherent in representations of the single
girl during the period
are seen.
Lehman’s book
initially explores the roots of the single girl in the
film adaptation of
Helen Gurley Brown’s 1962 bestseller Sex and the
Single Girl,
the Doris Day and Rock Hudson films of the 1960s, and
lesser-known films such
as Boy’s Night Out (1962). All of these films
are notable for the
ways in which they mute and subvert any real
representations of
sexuality; indeed the titles and premises of the
films are often much
more tantalizing than anything you will see on
the screen. Truly, the
only theme related to women’s sexuality that
gets explicit
treatment is the danger involved in even appearing to
be sexually available.
This is evident in the film Where the Boys Are
(1960), where one of
the main characters survives a sexual assault.
These films, authored
and directed by men, reveal “the deep fear and
suspicion they may
have felt toward single women” (66).
Lehman’s second
chapter explores the theme of leaving home and
the lure of urban life
in television series like That Girl (1966–1971)
and Peyton
Place (1964–1969), and films such as Thoroughly
Modern
Millie (1967)
and The Valley of the Dolls (1967). These television series
and films offered
wildly divergent treatment of the journey of
the single girl, often
influenced by the intervention of network and
film industry censors,
or in the case of That Girl, the power of an
influential star.
Chapters three and
four link several demographic trends to the
representations of
single women in the 1970s, and consider the use
of sexuality and power
in single girl narratives. These chapters take
us through familiar
territory, examining The Mary Tyler Moore Show
and other staples of
1970s television. Lehman reiterates the obvious
limitations of these
series while pointing out the major strides these
representations
exhibit when compared to series offered just a few
years prior. The
analysis in these chapters shines brightest when it
considers short-lived
television series such as Funny Face (1971–
1972), Shirley’s
World (1971–1972), Diana (1973–1974), and most
notably Get
Christie Love (1974–1975), the first series to feature an
African-American
female character in a title role for a dramatic series
on network television
(this would not happen again until the ABC
series Scandal
premiered in 2012). In many ways the failed series
and obscure B-films
and television movies Lehman considers are
more fruitful
artifacts than the better known and successful shows
and films.
The final chapter, “Courting
Danger,” is the most original and
promising. It examines
single women and the dangers of casual sex
in films such as Sheila
Levine is Dead and Living in New York (1975)
and Looking
for Mr. Goodbar (1977). Lehman is careful to note that
the thread of danger
in single girl narratives is not unique to the
late 1970s, but is
prominent in the plots of films considered earlier
in the book, Where
the Boys Are (1960) and For Singles Only (1968).
She examines popular
press accounts that blamed sexually aggressive
women for a host of
societal problems and argues that news media’s
attempts to
pathologize single women are also found in popular dramatic
films and novels that “highlighted
women’s self-destructive
tendencies” (210).
Lehman begins her consideration of Looking for
Mr. Goodbar with
the assertion that the controversy the film generated
“marks Mr.
Goodbar as a particularly important film,” but then
spends only a few
pages discussing it. This is a missed opportunity
to have ended this
chapter, and the book as a whole, with a much
more bold and
substantive conclusion.
Perhaps one of the
reasons Lehman’s work is notable are the many
scholars with whom her
work is in conversation. Lehman acknowledges
her indebtedness to
the work of media scholars Bonnie Dow,
Susan Douglas, and
Shelia Levine, and historians such as Beth Bailey
and Jane Gerhard.
Lehman’s book, like the works of these scholars,
help us understand how
popular media play a vital role in allowing
us to interpret and
negotiate moments of social change. The examples
offered speak to the
ability of popular film and television to
either take chances or
to succumb to more conservative impulses.
I offer two major
criticisms of the book. First, a book with this
title should have
spent more time on the print culture of the era,
one of the main venues
where one finds “single girl discourse” during
the period. Lehman
most often uses books and magazines merely
to frame her
discussion of television and film. Second, Lehman could
have developed one of
the more novel and compelling themes in her
analysis, the element
of risk and danger associated with many single
girl narratives, a bit
more. As feminist critics have pointed out, and
Lehman’s media
analysis makes clear, sexuality presents opportunities
for both pleasure and
danger for women. It is a shame that more
media representations
(both past and present) do not find more creative
ways to engage the
former.
Chadwick
Roberts
University
of North Carolina Wilmington
No comments:
Post a Comment